18 May 2007

It's Spring Cleaning Time

Every spring, I clean out all the closets, cabinets and shelves. I make a valiant effort toward minimalism until… until I reach the garage and panic!!!

To be sure that some of my service organizations are grateful for my donations. But, this year I started to think about how I sort all my “artifacts” for disposal. My basic “rule” is that if I haven’t used something in over a year it’s out like ‘80s parachute pants. Yet, I still hold onto things that I think I may need tomorrow. Insecurity, nostalgia, unwillingness to change and let go… all keep me from just getting rid of “stuff”.

This year, I though about how spring cleaning could be applied to how we work. We all use processes and methods that we cling to not because they actually provide any value but because of our security with them… our nostalgia for things comfortable and our unwillingness to change. What if in our work we did a bit of “spring cleaning”? What if we really sat down, looked at the true value our processes bring to our work, our lives and, most importantly, the lives of our customers and took an honest approach to determining their value? Wouldn’t we find that at least some of what we do really provides us with no value any more? And, like my our old, moth-hole riddled sweaters, if we aren’t getting any value out of the processes as we once did, many ages ago, shouldn’t we toss them?

Maybe, at least, once a year, we should advocate a bit a spring cleaning in our organizations. We should really look at what our customers “now” expect from us and learn whether or not our processes are really meeting those expectations. And, like our old suits we cannot fit into anymore, toss the processes that don’t serve our customers, or ourselves, well.

05 May 2007

BPM consultants should be SME's in... well BPM

Every sales cycle I endure the ploethera of calls asking for help in BPM but requiring subject matter expertise in a potential client's business. This is a dangerous requirement for BPM unplugged consultants. After all, our subject matter expertise needs to be in BPM.

When I think about successful customer outcomes for my own practice I think about what my real value is to my clients. It's getting them to be customer-centric in their culture, strategies, people and processes. So, when a potential client requires that I have certain subject matter expertise in some function or industry it's a pretty sure sign that what they are looking for is someone to deal with the details of its day to day business. But, this is not the role of a BPM consultant. Our role is to help our clients harvest the knowledge from their subject matter experts and facilitate an environment where they can be truly creative in addressing issues and conceiving solutions that change their future.

Many of my clients have been telecommunications companies. I've done much work in the high speed data and voice over IP (VoIP) domains. All of a sudden, potential clients see me as a high speed data or VoIP subject matter expert. I steadfastly deny any such claims. And, this is the danger. A BPM unplugged consultant who focuses on the subject matter of his/her client's business falls into two traps.

First, s/he ends up prescribing possible BPM solutions based upon his/her prejudiced knowledge of the subject matter. This constrains the consultant from being able to get his/her client and its team to think about new and different ways to solve current problems - to change for a better future. The result tends to be "built someplace else so it must work here" answer. At the very best, this gets the consultant's client to be only as good as the competitor where the solution was originally "built". This is not a great value-add for the client.

Second, s/he gets lost in the subject matter and loses perspective in the whole foundation of what BPM unplugged is all about.... successful customer outcomes. The consultant runs the risk of being just another subject matter expert within his/her client's organization, dealing with day-to-day problems. There is no focus on the future of doing things a whole new way. What's worse is a loss of that voice that says "let's not be just as good as the best competitor... let's be better."

When I talk to potential clients and the "subject" of subject matter expertise arises I quickly defer to my subject matter expertise... in BPM. Even with potential telecom clients, it is so easy to trip over things familiar to me. But, resisting the temptation and refocusing on what I do in BPM keeps me on track and solidifies what my potential client should expect from me. Then, if the potential client still wants to focus on understanding the subject matter of its business as a requirement, I know I must respectfully decline the engagement.

At the end of the day, we cannot be all things to all people. It's important to understand what my potential clients' successful customer outcomes with my consultation are. Equally as important is my recognition within the context of my own goals and objectives for BPM consulting whether I can actually or even want to meet them. And, if my potential client's expectation is that I be a subject matter expert in its business, then, that is one successful customer outcome I cannot meet.

12 April 2007

BPM Brainstorm Chicago

I just returned from Chicago and BPM Brainstorm Conference. Here is a summary of my findings for you BPM Unplugged fans. But, for an extremely detailed and insightful commentary you absolutely must read Sandy Kemsley's blog comments about the conference.

I am going to focus on two key presentations, which I found most useful as they pertain to BPM Unplugged.

PAT DOWDLE AND PROCESS BASED MANAGEMENT

The first presentation addressed a Roadmap to Implementing Process Based Management given by Pat Dowdle at CAM-I. Mr. Dowdle expresses that "Processes are how you provide products and services to your customers." His discussion centers around the idea that companies that employ PBM techniques are truly in tune with their customer's expectations.

As we discuss BPM Unplugged, the PBM approach is a perfect example of how any organization should structure their cultures, end-to-end processes, metric and initiatives around the customer. Most companies structure themselves along functional lines (sales, marketing, accounting, customer care, product development, service delivery, distribution, manufacturing, and so forth). However, when customers interact with a company, they are little concerned about these functional lines. As a result, companies tend to think about process within these lines and there is often a huge discrepancy between what the customer expects, and the experience with the company the customer actually gets.

Of the two most difficult concepts for companies to "get", I think are the "cultural" and "customer expectation" pieces. Culturally, most companies tend not to motivate and reward their senior executives and managers to be process & customer focused. So, in the end, the most these companies get is a set function-by-function processes which still segment, slice and dice customers across them. It also puts each function in possible conflict with other functions as they try to assume what they "think" their customers want from the company as a whole. In my opinion, focusing on the cultural changes that a company needs to address is the most challenging, but, the most liberating piece to the puzzle. The cultural change to be process-centric more easily leads the company into being truly customer-centric... then, the rest of the work becomes more understandable and achievable.

JEREMY ALEXIS AND FRAMEWORKS FOR BETTER DECISION MAKING

The second presentation addressed a Framework for Better Decision Making given by Jeremy Alexis at the Institute of Design at the Illinois Institute of Technology. Mr. Alexis presents us with an observation that we make decisions without a great deal of reflection or questioning. Once decisions are made, we tend to reserve reflection and questioning for later.

And, he hypothesizes that this is backwards. We should be spending more time on reflection and questioning before we actually make any initial decisions. Perhaps we do this because we are, generally, uncomfortable with the process of making decisions. In any event, this uncomfortable process leads to ideas which lack innovation, thought. They tend to be inwardly focused and unpromising which means they don't address the most important reason why we make decisions - to meet our customers' expectations.

If we think about this lack of decision making acumen in the context of a BPM project, specifically, or any project, in general, we would discover a mass of projects that go into development without direction or purpose - much less any value to a customer.

Mr. Alexis proposes, at the very high end, that we create an innovation strategy for decision making, triage concepts are they are created (with thoughtful reflection and questioning) and evaluate all concepts as triaged. But, what I fund most interesting is that an innovation strategy needs to be customer focused - a recurring theme on the BPM unplugged scene.

CONCLUSION
While there were many good presentations. I felt that these two stood out in their advocacy for more in depth focus on the strategic and cultural aspects of BPM that truly allow a company to be more customer-focused and far more successful in bringing to life a true BPM enabled company.

24 March 2007

Welcome to BPM Unplugged

I hope this blog will be a forum for discussing thoughts, ideas, trends and revelations in business process management – not from a technology perspective but from a “how do we structure our organizations around the customer?” perspective.

As customers become more informed, they have become elusive, demanding and unfaithful. Yet, as organizations scramble harder to get and keep these customers, they do things that, at best, ignore customers and, at worst, drive them away.

So, organizations are looking to BPM to save them. Yet, vast implementations of BPMS’, EAI applications, ERP systems, workflow engines, SOA frameworks and other technologies of assorted flavors and colors have become the shiny baubles and silver bullets of the BPM age.

What’s worse is that these implementations seem driven, more and more, by inward goals of “reducing cost”, “streamlining staff” and “improving efficiency”. Along the way, THE ONE most important piece, the centerpiece if you will, of the organization disappeared from the discussion – the customer.

So, let’s unplug the process modeling tools, the EAI applications and SOA. Let’s shut down the workflow engines. Grab a cup of joe and let’s return to a simpler world where customers are truly kings (or queens) and the organization, with BPM, crafts its entire world on getting and keeping them.

“The purpose of business is to create and keep a customer.” – Peter F. Drucker